That's right! This is the first HOG I ever reviewed, way back in 2011. It's also the third I'd actually played all the way through, soon after completing the first two Campfire Legend games. So please, join me on this jaunt back in time!
Up until a few months ago, I'd never actually played a hidden object game. They'd always seemed like the bailiwick of bored people at work looking to kill time while waiting for a phone call. My naive habit of horrible target audience stereotyping ended when I actually played one of these games on a whim, and was shocked to discover an incredibly good game—one that mixed hidden object hunts and puzzles seamlessly into a compelling narrative that pulled me inexorably towards a thrilling conclusion. Voodoo Chronicles: The First Sign isn't that game, but at least my eyes were opened before encountering it. If not, i would have likely missed out on nice little casual title.
The biggest challenge with reviewing a hidden object game is figuring out exactly what critical framework to use. Obviously it's largely a puzzle game, one that owes its origins to "spot-the-difference" and Where's Waldo? books, but there are also light action sequences, and a semblance of a plot tying everything together. So, how to approach it? After some (way too much, honestly) thought, I've come up with three criteria that, when judiciously applied, can be used to determine the quality of a hidden object game.
Criteria 1: To what degree do the puzzle screens look like a thrift store vomited on my monitor?
The game suffers a little from this phenomenon. It's always a challenge to come up with reasons for areas to be littered with random objects that have to be sorted through, and Voodoo Chronicles does better than most. The settings do include a ransacked office and crashed airship, so there's sometimes justification for the strewn goods. Still, there are far too many instances of "random object thrown in for no good reason" to give the game a pass. Especially egregious are the too-frequent appearances of bizarre scaling problems with objects. I think it's fair to expect item sizes to be fairly consistent—if I'm asked to look for a "pitchfork," I don't expect the game to mean a tiny utensil dwarfed by the sawblade lying next to it.
Criteria 2: Are the searches justified by the premise/story?
Only partially. The game follows the standard HOG trope of asking players to find a specific plot-related object in a given area, but then also forcing them to find twenty other random objects simply to pad out every puzzle screen. This is so common that it's almost foolish to complain about it, but it can be done more elegantly, and I'd appreciate it if more developers took the effort and stretched themselves in that direction. That way players won't find themselves asking why—while escaping from an underground prison—they need to find a pillow, basket, and monkey.
Criteria 3: How well do the various puzzles and object searches meld together to form a coherent whole?
This is hardest-to-quantify category, but also the most important. When it comes right down to it, this isn't a Where's Waldo? book, it's a game with a narrative, and as such I'm forced to ask how well the gameplay serves that. In this case, it actually works fairly well. Except for a bizarre endgame sequence, the puzzles and object searches all fit the mystery tone extremely well. The story is considerably less well-handed. While it's an effective enough over-the-top adventure, the decision to reveal the solution to the mystery in an opening cinema sequence is baffling at best. When I'm playing as a detective tasked with solving a high-profile mystery, I'd rather the game didn't tell me who did it and why in the first 90 seconds. Perhaps that's just me.
The game also has a few minor sticking points. A few of the object-based puzzles are on the non-intuitive side (the in-game guide that comes with the deluxe edition is quite useful), and the game can be oddly cavalier with language for something that largely depends on precision and specificity. The list of objects has a bad habit of using bottle, vase, and jar interchangeably—and when the shelves are filled with all three, figuring out what I'm supposed to click on becomes a challenge. The game also has a few odd translations—it took me more than a minute to discover that when the game said I needed to click on a "beam" it meant a pile of logs.
Despite these minor flaws, Voodoo Chronicles: The First Sign fulfilled my criteria for a quality HOG handily. While it may not be near the top of the genre, it's certainly a pleasant casual title. Easy on the eyes and just challenging enough to keep people from getting bored while waiting for that phone call. How much more can one ask from a Hidden Object Game?